Let's explore what causes the twinkling effect of stars. We will also explore why planets, sun and moon don't seem to twinkle. Created by Mahesh Shenoy.
Want to join the conversation?
- The Rays coming from the star undergoes several refractions by the layers of our atmosphere and the Rays always change it's directions from time to time so we can see the star twinkling but why don't we see the change in places of star due to the same reason??(6 votes)
- It's because you have no point of reference with which to compare it to. If you watch them when they are closer to the horizon and near a mountain peak or a building on the horizon, you will see them move around. But when you are looking into the sky, your eye is moving too, so your brain just dismisses the movement of the star thinking it's just your eye moving around since it has nothing relative to the star to compare it to. I hope that makes sense.(1 vote)
- What about a mirage? How does image formation occur in a mirage?(6 votes)
- What causes the stars to twinkle?(1 vote)
- Atmospheric Refraction
Stars are very far away from us and so we consider them to be point-sized light sources. When rays from the Stars reach the Earth's atmosphere they are continuously refracted many times [ Which is also the reason why they appear to be higher than their actual position specially when they are near the Horizon] & since the physical conditions on the Earth's atmosphere are not stationary, their paths are also continuously shifting. Due to these reasons all the rays from the Star do not necessarily reach our eyes at the same time and so appear to be bright at times and dim at the other. Therefore the stars appear to be twinkling, or in other words, the twinkling effect is visible to us.(4 votes)
- why does fire flicker? How is it related to twinkling of stars?(1 vote)
- It's not related. When we look at stars, their brightness is not changing, only the amount of light that reaches our eyes is changing. In regards to fire, the brightness is in fact changing, depending on what fuel and oxygen are available to the chemical reaction at any point in time, but all the light is reaching our eyes. These are separate phenomenon and aren't related.(1 vote)
- If refraction causes stars to twinkle, then why don't we see them in the form a spectrum?(1 vote)
- well as you know, not all refracting mediums form a spectrum. for example, prims do and glass slabs don't.(1 vote)
- sir, what if all the points which make a planet twinkle at the same time? will not look just like a star?(1 vote)
- what is 2 times 5?(1 vote)
- Why does the light bend when traveling through the atmosphere?(0 votes)
- Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, why do the stars twinkle at us and planets don't twinkle. Why don't planets twinkle? The stars only twinkle due to our atmosphere and we know this because if you look at the stars from outside our atmosphere like the astronauts on the space station, they don't see the stars twinkling at all. So let's explore how this atmosphere makes all the stars twinkle at us. So let's say we're standing over here on Earth, looking at this star. Now, due to our atmosphere, there are two things that are going to happen. First, as the light enters from space into the atmosphere, it's going to bend a little bit and this happens because the light decreases its speed. It slows down as it enters into our atmosphere just a little bit and as a result it refracts, it bends and because of this bending when we look at the star, it appears to us as if these rays of light are coming from somewhere higher in the sky and so when we look at the star, we don't see over here, we're going to see it a little bit higher. So the first effect of the atmosphere, is that it shifts the position of the star. This effect is greater when the stars are closer to the horizon because the rays of light pass through a larger part of the atmosphere. But the twinkling effect is not caused due to this. So what causes the twinkling effect? Well, if we were to zoom in and look at the light as it travels through our atmosphere, then we would see that as it travels down towards the Earth surface, light doesn't bend, light doesn't travel in a straight line where it continuously keeps bending. This happens because the light is passing through several layers of our atmosphere and as it passes from one layer to another, there is changes in the temperature, there is changes in the density, there's pollution and dust particles and because of this the light continuously keeps changing its speed as it moves from one layer to another and as a result light continuously keeps refracting or bending as it moves towards us. And more importantly, the temperature and the density of the air it's continuous fluctuating even with time, it changes with time continuously and as a result the path taken by the Light also slightly keeps changing. So the bending is not the same, the very next moment it might take a little different path and this causes the stars to twinkle. But why exactly? What happens if the light bends? Well, let's zoom in a little further. So let's say this is our eyes as you're looking at that star and currently let's say about five rays of light are reaching our eyes and because of this we are seeing, right now, the star to be as bright as we can see over here, but because the atmospheric conditions are continuously changing with time, maybe the very next moment the path taken by this light changes a little bit and as a result, let's say that one of these rays slightly bend away, missing our eyes. So, maybe the very next moment, instead of five, only four rays reach our eyes. Now because of four rays reaching our eyes, the star is gonna look a little bit dim. Maybe the next moment, only two rays reach our eyes. So now the star is going to look even more dim. And so you see, due to the continuous changes in the atmosphere, fluctuations in the temperature and density and all the other things, because the light is continuously changing its path, the rays that reach our eyes continuously changes and as a result the brightness of the star keeps changing. And this is what causes the twinkling effect of the stars. So the next question is, why don't planets twinkle? The answer is the planets actually do twinkle. In fact, everything outside our atmosphere, anything we're looking at outside your atmosphere does twinkle due to the effect that we discussed. However, we can't notice the twinkling effect of the planets because planets appear bigger in size to us. Let's go to a different screen. So here is the star, a star pretty much looks like a dot in the sky but if you would look at a planet, a planet actually appears much bigger in the sky. That's because the planets are much closer to us. Now, although we can't see that with our naked eyes, if you had to use a telescope and look at them, then starts would still look like a dot, but planets well we can actually make out their shape, if you're looking at Saturn we could actually see the rings of the Saturn and so on. So because planets are much bigger in the sky compared to the stars, we can assume the planets are made up of many such dots. The stars are the single dot, but we can assume that planets are made up of many such dots. And so, each of these dots will twinkle, just like a star but because we have many dots, when one of these dots become dim, some other dot will become bright. When that becomes dim, some other dot becomes bright and as a result, when we look at the planet as a whole, the overall brightness doesn't change much or doesn't fluctuate much. We can now actually see this effect in action. I have copied this twinkling dot and pasted it over here several times. So each of these dots are going to twinkle the same way, pretty much the same way. Then we'll zoom out and we'll look at them. All right, so let's play the animation. If you see carefully, you can actually note that all these dots are twinkling the same amount because I copy pasted them. But now, let's zoom out until both of these, the planet and the star pretty much look like a dot. And you can pretty much see that the brightness of the planet remains almost at constant. That's because on an average, the light from the planet pretty much remains the same. And that's why you can't make out the twinkling effect. Now, if you find it hard to see this on your mobile screen or something, then what we'll do is we'll zoom in a little bit and you can move away from the screen until both of them look like a dot to you. So move away until the star, the start is barely visible and the planet just looks like a dot. And then you can actually see the twinkling effect of the star but not of the planet. So to quickly summarize, we learned that the twinkling effect of the star is caused due to the fluctuations of the atmospheric conditions which make the star light bend as it moves towards us and as a result, the brightness of the star keeps changing. And this means everything that is outside of our atmosphere will twinkle but because planets have a bigger size, the twinkling effect cannot be made out with our eyes and for the same reason the Sun and the Moon also don't seem to twinkle for us. And this twinkling effect is pretty annoying for astronomers who use their telescope and try to take the photographs of our planets or the galaxies because the photos don't come out very crisp and it's for that reason we built the Hubble Space Telescope. The idea was to build a telescope and make sure that it orbits around the earth, outside our atmosphere. Then it will not be affected by the twinkling effect and as a result the photographs produced by the Hubble Space Telescope is unaffected by the atmosphere fluctuations and that's why these photographs are extremely crisp and extremely useful for scientific research.