Europe 1300 - 1800
- A miraculous appearance for a queen: Juan de Flandes, Christ Appearing to His Mother
- A wedding and a miracle for the queen of Spain: Juan de Flandes, Marriage at Cana
- The Cantino Planisphere
- Bringing the figure to life, Berruguete at The Met
- Bringing the figure to life, Berruguete at The Met
- Alonso Berruguete, Abraham and Isaac
- Fernando Yáñez de la Almedina, Head of Christ
- The Tower of Belém
- Belém Monstrance
- Alejo Fernández, Virgin of the Navigators
- Sacred geometry in a Renaissance ceiling from Spain
- El Escorial, Spain
- El Greco, Burial of the Count Orgaz
- El Greco, View of Toledo
- El Greco, Adoration of the Shepherds
El Greco, View of Toledo
El Greco, View of Toledo, 1596-1600, oil on canvas, 47 3/4 x 42 3/4” / 121.3 x 108.6 cm (The Metropolitan Museum of Art)
Not just any sky
Landscape paintings are often meant to document the look of a particular time in a particular place, to freeze a single moment and preserve it for eternity. El Greco’s View of Toledo does not do that. Although the large church is placed in the correct place in the city, El Greco changed the locations of several other buildings, proving that documentation was not the artist’s primary concern. Rather than telling us what Toledo looked like, here, El Greco communicates what the city feels like. Toledo becomes the means through which the artist expresses an interior psychological state, and perhaps, a view about the nature of man’s relationship with the divine.
Using typically dark, moody colors, El Greco presented the Spanish city of Toledo at the top of a rolling hill. The city itself takes up only a little space in the center of the painting. The landscape and sky dominate. This is not just any sky. El Greco’s clouds are about to crack open and unleash a storm on the city. The buildings themselves seem to crawl across the painting, and curving lines throughout the hill give the impression that the vista is moving, that it might actually be alive.
El Greco, View of Toledo, 1596-1600 (detail)
In El Greco’s Toledo, something is about to happen, and it probably isn’t going to be good.
Something new: a cityscape
To understand how radical this painting is, we have to weigh a few historical circumstances. First, El Greco was painting in Counter Reformation Spain, where religious dictates based on the Council of Trent (which ended in 1563), banned the landscape as a suitable subject for painting. Although the church was his primary patron, the artist broke with that convention, and because of this, View of Toledo has been called the first Spanish landscape. More impressively, cityscapes never existed anywhere in the sixteenth century. El Greco may literally have invented the genre. Some art historians found this so unsettling that they had suggested that, because El Greco often included views of Toledo in the backgrounds of his religious paintings and portraits, View of Toledo may have actually been cut from the background of a larger painting. However, we now know that this is not true.
The city of Toledo
Although El Greco, “the Greek,” is most usually known as a Spanish painter, he was born Domenikos Theotokopouolos in Crete in 1541, and spent much of his life in Italy. He was trained in the tradition of Byzantine icon paintings in either Crete or Venice, where many Cretans had settled, and by the 1560s was painting in Titian’s workshop. In the 1570s he went to Rome. Although El Greco was well reputed in Italy, he failed to secure any commissions in the city, and was convinced by a Spaniard to move to Toledo, where he spent the next forty years of his life, and where he died in 1614.
Why did the city of Toledo inspired El Greco to paint such a powerful picture of the city? In Spain, El Greco failed to find favor with the king, and instead worked for the Catholic Church. If he was not raised in the faith, he almost certainly would have had to convert to Catholicism. In the 1500s, Spain’s Catholic Church had undergone huge transformations. The century started with the Spanish Inquisition, in which non-Catholics were hunted out, tried, tortured, and often, killed. At the same time, people, like Saint Theresa of Avilla and Saint Ignatius of Loyola (both Spanish), were preaching that, through prayer, one could be directly inspired by God, and they claimed to have frequent visions in which God spoke to them. Because of their beliefs, even these saints came under the scrutiny of the Inquisition, although they were eventually acquitted. Spain’s brand of Catholicism, compared to Italy’s, was mystical and based on personal experience.
Mysticism and Inner Conflict
This mysticism is reflected in El Greco’s View of Toledo. Almost entirely subsumed by the landscape, the city seems to be at the direct mercy of God. This is not a forgiving God, but rather a wrathful one, as in the Old Testament. Toledo is undergoing a reckoning. At the same time, the landscape transcends this religious reading. It becomes reflective of the inner conflict of each human being, the feeling that making one’s way in the world is a harrowing endeavor.
Left: El Greco, View of Toledo; right: Van Gogh, Starry Night, 1889
View of Toledo was centuries ahead of its time, and probably can best be compared to Vincent van Gogh’s Starry Night, 1889, which contains many of the same compositional elements (a swirling sky, overwhelming nature, a skyline dominated by a church). But whereas van Gogh evokes the calm of a little sleeping town, El Greco’s painting captures the violence of the exterior world against an interior one.
Giorgione, The Tempest, c. 1506-08 (Accademia, Venice)
In this way, View of Toledo has much in common with Giorgione’s The Tempest, in which a crack of lightning and oncoming storm threaten a woman and child seated in the landscape. El Greco reminds us that there is an unfriendly world outside of us and that we are all subject to forces beyond our control. He leaves it up to us to decide whether we will succumb or prevail.
Text by Christine Zappella
Want to join the conversation?
- I have heard that some art historians believe El Greco may have suffered from some type of distortion of vision, like an astigmatism or cataract, that caused him to see the world in elongated figures. Do you know if there is any research to back up this claim?(5 votes)
- I think most art historians are unsympathetic to the many popular efforts that seek to "explain" style by way of physical impairment. In my view it is much more interesting to think about why these ideas are popular nevertheless.(7 votes)
- "...religious dictates based on the Council of Trent...banned the landscape as a suitable subject for painting."
Why? Was it just that they thought that only explicitly religious subjects should be painted? What was it about landscapes that threatened the Church?(4 votes)
- I believe that those in Protestant countries typically painted secular works like landscape paintings. Sometimes the paintings included pagan art, which the Church did not like.
And since the Council of Trent was during the Counter-Reformation, I think they wanted to make as many explicit religious paintings as possible to overpower the Reformation movement.(4 votes)
- Christine, I enjoyed your commentary greatly, with one exception. In your "Mysticism and Inner Conflict" section, you refer to the "wrathful" rather than "forgiving" God, "as in the Old Testament." That dichotomy is a strictly Christian view (as is the use of "Old Testament," rather than "Hebrew Bible"). One is of course free to hold that view, but your commentary would be more universal if you avoided that description, or at least made clear that it's a specifically sectarian viewpoint.(2 votes)
- The author is not referring to Christianity in a general sense, she is writing about a particular place at a particular time.(3 votes)
- Hasn't recent information concerning the Inquisition -- specifically, the Vatican's more open records, since 2000 -- caused a bit of a volte-face over the popular historical opinion dubbed the Black Legend? I'm not certain how widely historians, and art historians, regard this to be true, but how might it change your interpretation of this painting? Or wouldn't it?(2 votes)
- How are we so certain that "El Greco" even produced these works in this time frame? Given how absolutely radical they are! I have seen nothing like these works until now for this era. I instantly thought of impressionism and was stunned to see that these works are supposed to come from the 1500's! Do we have more information about "El Greco" and dates of other works of his perhaps?(1 vote)
- Quite a lot is known about El Greco. Wikipedia is always a good place to start: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Greco
I think he was quite famous in his lifetime: his painting The Burial of the Count of Orgaz is set in the 14th century, but depicts famous people at the Spanish court in then-modern dress, including Miguel de Cervantes.(2 votes)
- "More impressively, cityscapes never existed anywhere in the sixteenth century."
What about the Urbino panels?(1 vote)
- ...proves the rule, doesn't it. There were cityscapes earlier, the Urbino panels, and before that Lorenzetti's Allegory of Good Gov't. in the City. I think she meant what she wrote, in the 16th c.(1 vote)
- El Greco May not have had stigmatism in his eyes he lived on a holy place of the blessed mother Mary so it's very likely he was blessed by holy spirits and if I 'm not mistaken he has painted the mother Mary ascending into Heaven in his painting "View of Toledo". Am I right? He was a student of Titian wasn't he? It isn't an allusion that she is depicted in the clouds is it? I too painted long figures in mist when I was a teenager and I was dedicated and still am to the Virgin mother, just like he may have been. Why did authorities in Spain in that century not allow cityscapes to be painted by artists? Thanks to El Greco we have at least one mega magnificent landscape of the city and the mighty Heavens opening up not to predict an onerous disaster but to welcome one of its own home!
I have wished and hoped to visit this place of ancestry all my life and I cannot explain why save and except for its sheer omnipresence. Unfortunately I will not get the chance to do so...a bucket list must.