Main content
Europe 1300 - 1800
Course: Europe 1300 - 1800 > Unit 2
Lesson 4: Pisa and Rome, the Late GothicPietro Cavallini, The Last Judgment
Pietro Cavallini, The Last Judgment, c.1293, fresco, Santa Cecilia, Rome This fresco was discovered in 1900 and represents one of the few works by Cavallini to survive. Created by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker.
Want to join the conversation?
- Would artists have had physical descriptions of the Disciples from the bible or are they going more off of their imagination?(8 votes)
- Totally from imagination. The first images of the apostles were several hundred years after Christ and, even then, highly stylized.(5 votes)
- Who's the one guy, second to the left, that isn't looking towards Christ? Is this significant?(7 votes)
- He is not looking towards Christ because he is the one who will betray Christ and lead to his death, so he feels guilt and does not want Christ to know it was him.(7 votes)
- Why has the fresco not been repaired? Also, although there is a rounding to the robes which gives a richness to them, the faces chairs are so angular or elongated. Is this a transition from the Byzantine? I enjoyed the video.(3 votes)
- They were uncovered in the early 20th century and I believe already in their current state of disrepair. The modern philosophy about art conservation and restoration is that we preserve for the future and only restore with methods that are non-destructive and non-deceptive to a keen observer. Fresco painting is a challenge because by its nature it must be created on fresh plaster which would mean dramatically adding to or altering the original work for repairs. If this piece were being privately displayed for someone's personal pleasure, restoration might be considered, but as part of humanity's heritage, this painting deserves only to be cleaned and stabilized for posterity.
Now on your thoughts about transitioning out of the Byzantine, yes this certainly lays a foundation for that. We are seeing the traditional artwork, contemporary to this time, mixed with some naturalist concepts from the classical works; or at least an interest in realism and perspective. Nothing too radical, but to an observer such as yourself, perfectly visible.(8 votes)
- How did they remove the fresco from the church? If it was painted directly onto the plaster on the walls, it seems like it would be difficult to move it.(4 votes)
- These frescos are still in situ (in their original location). They have not been removed (although it looks like that in the photos). The were covered at some point and then discovered at the very beginning of the 20th century.(5 votes)
- The form the angel wings are realized looks quite modern to me, and I have so far seen nothing in the same style for this period before. Was this kind of "revolutionary" or a total exception at that time? Also, the pattern of the wings seem to go into the background at- and I think I saw another "background resemblance" with an apostle's hands. I would like to see more of that. 3:35(3 votes)
- You are right, the wings do appear different! Although I don't think Cavallini has made any dramatic innovations here.
For example, Cimabue's angels also have this style of wing, just smaller and a little less detailed. Here are two Madonnas from 1280 and 1280-85:
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/8/8c/Cimabue_-_Maest%C3%A0_du_Louvre.jpg
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/b/be/Cimabue_Trinita_Madonna.jpg
Here is another 13th century angel from a fresco of St. Benedict's funeral.
https://cdn.superstock.com/1788/Thumb/1788-54512.jpg
Giotto also uses this style in some of his angels, although it is simplified. (Usually, though, his angels' wings tend to look more like "real" bird wings, with fewer variation in hue.) http://www.wga.hu/art/g/giotto/z_panel/2panel/42maesta.jpg
I'm inclined to think there was an evolution in angel wing painting, with some adding pattern and color (like Cavallini) and some rejecting it for naturalism (like Giotto). Cavallini has just made them larger and more detailed.(3 votes)
- Why are the 6 apostles on Christ's right armed to the teeth but the 6 apostles on Christ's left are bearing symbols of the Church? Historically, I know that the right side of Jesus Christ is considered to be the righteous side (it's in the word!), so is the artist hinting that open defenders or crusaders are in higher regards than members of the clergy in the eyes of God? Also, Mary is on Christ's left and John the Baptist on the right, so what are we saying here? This is depicted well at. 2:17(1 vote)
- The left/right orientation so common in Last Judgment scenes does not carry over into the court of heaven which is where the figures you reference are. I'd caution against reading their placement through that lens.(5 votes)
- I understand Gothic as an architectural form, but what makes this fresco, and the Berglinghieri's St. Francis Altarpiece, Gothic, other than just being from the Gothic period.(3 votes)
- It is already what we call proto-renaissance (as the general name of the section says), but still much time before the actual renaissance. What was in between, is usually called also late (or international) Gothic. Gothic was changing throughout years and transition to what we call "renaissance" was rather smooth. Check the section "Introduction to Gothic", which shows how diverse the actual Gothic art was.(1 vote)
- are john the evangilest and john the baptist the same person(1 vote)
- And let us not ignore St. John the Divine, who wrote the Revelation! "John" (with it's Aramaic, Hebrew, Greek and Latin variations) was a common name at the time.(3 votes)
- I don't understand where this fresco is. At, i can't see any fresco - have i missed something? 0:20
Is it behind the more recently built 'balcony'?
i'm going to Rome next week and would like to see this.(1 vote)- it is behind the wall above the front door of the nave. It is only accessible two mornings per week if I remember correctly. Ring the bell and up a few steps and to the left of the main door to the church before you go in (while still out in the courtyard). A nun will let you upstairs.(2 votes)
- At, the undertitles and transcript refer to "Jato". This must be a spelling mistake: surely they are referring to "Giotto"? 1:22(1 vote)
Video transcript
(piano music) Man: We're in Santa Cecilia
in Rome looking at the ruins of an extraordinary fresco by Cavallini from the late thirteenth century. Woman: We're above the
entrance to the church and we're looking directly at a fresco that in the late thirteenth century people would have looked up at and it's a scene of the last judgment. Man: Right so this would
have been on the wall opposite the altar and this
would have been the last thing you saw as you
were leaving the church. It's a monumental fresco. You see Christ in the
center in a mandorla, that is a kind of divine
emanation or halo that surrounds his entire body. He sits here as judge over
the souls that have lived. Woman: And he exhibits for us very clearly the wounds of the crucifixion. We can see holes from
the nails in his feet and his hands, and the wound in his side that is bleeding. A reminder of Christ's suffering. His return now is judge of mankind. Man: He is framed by angels on either side and beyond that we can see the apostles, six on each side. Between the apostles and
Christ there were two other figures. You have Mary on Christ's right and you have John the
Baptist on Christ's left. Woman: And we're so clearly at just before the time of Jato in
the way these prefigure what Jato will do in the very early years of the fourteenth century. Man: Right. This is
known as Roman realism. He's clearly borrowing from the Byzantine but there is a kind of unprecedented interest in creating a sense of naturalism as figures of our world. Woman: That can be seen in how heavily the figures are all modeled. There is not thin elongated
forms created by line, but really monumental forms created
by the use of light and dark. Man: You can see that
use of light and dark very consistently in
the furniture as well, and the light makes it very believable. The line is drawn so that
there is a precocious attempt at a kind of perspective. Not true linear perspective of course, but something that is very
much trying to explain how these angles function in space as one looks up from below. Woman: That's right, especially
evident in the seats that the apostles sit in. They angle
inward toward the center. So it's as though they
really are thinking about us as the viewer in the center
looking up at Christ. Man: There is a kind
of sensitivity in terms of rhythm and especially
color in this painting that is so beautiful. Look at the apostles. You have alternations of
violet blues, red blues, grey blues, green against
a warmer kind of grey moving across so that
there is never a repeat of the color, just beautiful. Woman: And we get a sense of a three-dimensional body
underneath that drapery. If you look at the apostles, we can see the drapery
pulling around their bellies, around their shoulders, in
the folds around their arms. Giving us a sense of monumental figures that really haven't been
seen since ancient Rome. Man: It's interesting
to think about this move from the spiritual
rendering that is a kind of symbolized body to
one that is dimensional, one that takes up space, and this idea that there is a proximity between the way in which these figures are rendered and the
bodies that we inhabit. Woman: And the kind of human emotions that we feel. If you look at the figure
of Saint John the Baptist with his hands clasped in prayer, the way that he moves
his eyebrows together and there are wrinkles in his forehead and he looks toward Christ. There is a real sense of individuality to these figures and a
sense of human emotion as they look toward Christ. Man: But these are
still clearly coming out of the Byzantine tradition. If you look at the face of Christ we might be looking at a mosaic from Ravenna from Constantinople. Woman: That's right. This moment at the end of the 1200s, the beginnings of the
1300s when we have this imminent naturalism. Man: Of course Catallini
does not know that is coming. That's our hindsight. Nevertheless, we can see
this kind of painting along with the sculptures
of Pisano or perhaps the work of Cimabue as
we're beginning to move into what will eventually
become the Renaissance. (piano music)