If you're seeing this message, it means we're having trouble loading external resources on our website.

If you're behind a web filter, please make sure that the domains ***.kastatic.org** and ***.kasandbox.org** are unblocked.

Main content

Current time:0:00Total duration:4:41

- [Instructor] So we've been
given the value of h of x at a few values of x, and then we're told, James said that since h
of seven minus h of three over seven minus three is equal to one. So this is really the
average rate of change between x is equal to three
and x is equal to seven, between that point and that
point right over there. So since that is equal to one, there must be a number
c in the closed interval from three to seven for
which the derivative at that value c is equal to one. So what James is trying to do is apply the Mean Value Theorem, which tells us if the conditions apply for the Mean Value Theorem, it tells us that if I'm
going through two values, so let's say this is
a, let's say this is b, and let's say the function
does something like this. If we meet the conditions
for the Mean Value Theorem, it tells us that there's
some c in the closed interval from a to b where the
derivative of c is equal to the average rate of
change between a and b. So the average rate of
change between a and b would be the slope of the
secant line right over there, and then we could just think about well, looks like there are some points. The way I've drawn it, that point right over there
seems to have the same slope. This point right over there
seems to have the same slope. And so that's all what the
Mean Value Theorem is claiming, that there's going to be at least one c, if we meet the conditions
for the Mean Value Theorem, where the derivative at
that point is the same as the average rate of change
from the first endpoint to the second. Now what are the conditions
for the Mean Value Theorem to apply, and we've reviewed
this in multiple videos. One way to think about it, if we're talking about the closed interval from three to seven, one condition is that you
have to be differentiable, differentiable, over the open interval from three to seven. So that's the interval but
not including the endpoints. And you have to be continuous continuous over the entire closed interval so including the endpoints. And one interesting thing
that we've mentioned before is that differentiability
implies continuity. So if something is differentiable
over the open interval, it's also going to be continuous
over this open interval, and so the second condition
would just say well then we also have to be continuous at the endpoints. Now let's look at the answers. So it says which condition
makes James's claim true? So we have to feel good
about these two things right over here in order
to make James's claim. Choice A, h is continuous
over the closed interval from three to seven. So that does meet this second condition, but continuity does not
imply differentiability. So that doesn't give us the confidence that we're differentiable
over the open interval. If you're differentiable
you're continuous, but if you're continuous you're not necessarily differentiable. Classic example of that is
if we have a sharp turn, something like that, we wouldn't be
differentiable at that point even though we are continuous there. So let me rule that one out. I'm gonna rule that one out. Choice B, h is continuous and decreasing over the closed interval
from three to seven. Now that doesn't help us either because it still doesn't
mean you're differentiable. You could be continuous
and then decreasing and still have one of these sharp turns where you're not differentiable. So we will rule this one out. H is differentiable
over the closed interval from three to seven. This one feels good because if you're differentiable
over the closed interval, you're definitely gonna be differentiable over the open interval that
does not include the endpoints. This is a subset of this right over here. And if you're differentiable
over a closed interval, you're gonna be continuous over it. Differentiability implies continuity. So I like this choice right over here. Now this last choice says the
limit as x approaches five of h prime of x is equal to one. So they're saying the
limit of our derivative as we approach five is equal to one. Now that doesn't, we don't know for sure, this limit might be true, but that still does not necessarily imply that h prime of five is equal to one. We sill don't know that. And you know five is in this interval, but we still don't know just
from this statement alone that there is definitely
some c in the interval whose derivative is the same
as the average rate of change over the interval. So I would rule this one out as well.