Main content
Medieval Europe + Byzantine
Course: Medieval Europe + Byzantine > Unit 9
Lesson 3: Romanesque art in France- Saint Trophime, Arles
- Cistercian Abbey of Fontenay (UNESCO/NHK)
- Pentecost and Mission to the Apostles Tympanum, Vézelay
- Basilica of Saint-Sernin
- Fontenay Abbey
- Last Judgment Tympanum, Cathedral of St. Lazare, Autun
- Church and Reliquary of Sainte‐Foy, France
- Last Judgment Tympanum (Autun) Quiz
- Cluny Abbey
- Saint-Pierre, Moissac
- Casket with troubadours
© 2023 Khan AcademyTerms of usePrivacy PolicyCookie Notice
Pentecost and Mission to the Apostles Tympanum, Vézelay
Pentecost and Mission to the Apostles Tympanum, central portal of the narthex, Basilica Ste-Madeleine, Vézelay, France, 1120-32 Speakers: Dr. Beth Harris and Dr. Steven Zucker. Created by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker.
Want to join the conversation?
- Where is Jesus's left hand?(5 votes)
- Maybe it was intentionally left off, as you never hear about that, but instead "the right hand of Christ" that gets all of the attention and mention. It could have been a statement, though I don't know for sure either way. Hope this helps, T.S.(7 votes)
- At the day of Pentecost the Holy Ghost wasn't given so the apostles could talk to people that spoke in different languages. The Holy Ghost was when God's spirit came to live inside the apostles to give them power. They knew they had it by evidence of speaking in tongues.(4 votes)
- Very good points about the art of the time reflecting the ignorance and isolation of the European world at the time! Art certainly developed more quickly as the world became more connected into the renaissance and unbelievably so in the more modern industrial period.(4 votes)
- I haven't yet heard anything about the pagan religions that would have preceded this pan-christian Europe that was partially brought about by the crusades. Could we hear more about them?(1 vote)
- It might be somewhere else, as this is are history, not religious history.(3 votes)
- Perhaps the "large ear people" represent a legend which represents the people of Africa that put increasingly larger cylindrical objects in their ears which render giant ear lobes?(2 votes)
- Interesting interpretation! Although you must remember: this was carved in the early 12th century, when Europe had relatively few interactions with other lands. Even merchants and explorers would have been unlikely to have seen such people, because they would have interacted with mostly Muslims (at this time, North African rulers and merchants were mostly Muslim, even in kingdoms such as Ghana and Mali where most people practiced traditional animism). Even if they had seen people with such piercings, it's unlikely this information would have reached these artists in its entirety, and that they would have decided to use it to decorate a scene such as this.(1 vote)
Video transcript
(piano playing) Beth: We've just walked
up a very steep hill, in the town of Vézelay,
in Burgundy, in France, and we're in the Church of La Madeleine. Steven: We're in the narthex, actually, which is the forecourt inside the church, before you walk into the Basilica itself, and, in the second set of doorways, on the main portal above, are a set of incredible tympana, but the central one is just astonishing. This is among the first
large scale figural sculpture of the late medieval period. Beth: This is a very important church. It houses the relics of Mary Magdalene. It was the place where one of the pilgrimage routes began. Steven: The pilgrimage
routes that worshippers could follow, on their way to Santiago de Compostela, in Spain, from church to church, from set of relics to set of relics. Beth: This church is
important for the relics, and is a place where a
pilgrimage route began, but it's also important
because this was the place that the Second and Third Crusades began. Steven: The First Crusade,
which began in 1095, was an attempt by Christians, in the West, to retake Jerusalem from the Muslims. Now, of course, this was a
terribly violent campaign and, although, they were
initially successful, ultimately, they were driven out. The second campaign was called by the Abbot Clairvaux
who wanted the Crusaders to go forth into non-Christian lands and to convert those foreigners. This idea of moving out
and converting the world is reflected in the subject
matter of this tympanum. Beth: In the center, we see Christ with 6 Apostles on either side. Christ is giving his
Um,ission to the Apostles to spread the Gospel to all peoples of all nations, and all creatures. Steven: You can see, actually, that they're all holding books. Those would be the Gospels themselves that they're going to be preaching, and, if you look very closely, you can see that there are rays, miraculous representations of light, that are reaching from Christ's fingers to the Apostles themselves. Beth: Some art historians have interpreted this scene as the Mission to the Apostles, and some as the event that happened, 10 days later, of the Pentecost, when the Holy Spirit
descended on the Apostles and they were given the ability to speak in many languages to convert the peoples of the Earth. Steven: This tympanum is quite deliberate in representing the host
peoples of the Earth, and, in a sense, the
strangeness of the world beyond Christian borders. Beth: The world was very small in the early 12th century. Steven: That's true. The Europeans really didn't know much about the world beyond their borders. The First Crusaders had come back with marvelous stories,
and they had spoken of people from southern Asia who had ears large enough to wrap themselves in. Beth: And, we see that on this tympanum. Steven: That's right.
They spoke of small people that needed ladders to
get up on to their horses, and that's represented
also, literally, here. This really speaks to the ignorance and, in some ways, the
fear that people here had of the worlds that they didn't know. Beth: In the center of this tympanum, we see Christ in a mandorla,
a kind of body halo. Steven: But, he breaks out of it. He's so powerful, and so large, that even that spiritual
light can't contain him. Beth: And, he's very thin, and elongated. Steven: He's also really elegant. Look at how his posture
is somewhat to the side. The knees are together, but they're pushed to our right, and I suspect that this
was one of the ways that his divinity is represented. Look at his body. You're absolutely right. He's very flat, very
linear, very attenuated. Look at the way in which patterns are so carefully rendered. There are those marvelous kinds of swirls, and it's as if the cloth itself is a sign of his spirituality. Beth: Well, and I think
there's a divine energy that seems to run through the figures in their gestures and their limbs. Steven: Christ is the largest figure. He dominates everything. Beth: And, here we are,
in the early 12th century, at this moment of the
rebirth of monumental sculpture in the West. Steven: Some scholars have suggested that the stylization,
especially of the cloth, can be seen in representations in painting from this time, especially
paintings from Cluny, the large Benedictine
church just south of here. Beth: Then, actually, there's one example that survives, of
painting, from that period, at Berzé-la-Ville, that
some scholars suggest this resembles. Steven: It makes sense
that, since large scale figural sculpture was just being revived, that artists would look to other media for systems of representation. Let's take a look at the sculpture itself. We have Christ in the
middle, as we've established. We have the Apostles on either side, and then, down in the
lintel, we have the peoples of the world, from different
historical periods. We have, perhaps, the
ancient Greeks, on the left, that need to be converted. Just above the tympanum itself, there are a series of compartments. They also reflect this idea of conversion. Beth: And, specifically,
the power that Christ gave the Apostles to save and condemn, to preach the Gospel to
all nations and creatures, to heal the sick, to drive out demons. We see, for example, the
conversion of the Jews. Steven: We see people with heads of dogs. We see people who are blind who can see. I mean, it's a series of miracles that's meant to inspire. But, I think it's crucial
that all of this reference to the New Testament is
also, at the same time, meant to be an inspiration
for medieval men to go out and convert, to go out and save. Beth: In the very place
where Bernard of Clairvaux called for the Second Crusades. (piano playing)