Main content
Europe 1300 - 1800
Christus, A Goldsmith in his Shop
A conversation with Dr. Steven Zucker and Dr. Beth Harris in front of Petrus Christus, A Goldsmith in his Shop, 1449, oil on oak panel, 100.1 x 85.8 cm (The Metropolitan Museum of Art). Created by Smarthistory.
Video transcript
(gentle music) - [Steven] We're in one
of the quietest parts of The Metropolitan Museum of Art. This is the Lehman Collection,
reconstructed to look like the interior of his
apartment, with walls of silk and furniture and some real treasures, including a painting that
we're standing in front of, Petrus Christus's "A
Goldsmith in his Shop". - [Beth] When you walk into this room, what you see mostly are
religious paintings. And with this painting, we're looking at
something that is secular, although for a long time, we thought it had a religious meaning. - [Steven] It was only a few years ago that a halo was removed
from the man seated. That halo was not original but had thrown art
historians for some time. - [Beth] The other thing that we see in this room are portraits. And in fact, now that this
halo has been removed, we can see this painting
much more in the light of a portrait than a religious painting. - [Steven] But this is
one complicated portrait because it includes five figures
and lots and lots of stuff. - [Beth] So for a long
time, that man in red was thought to be the
patron saint of goldsmiths, a saint who is especially associated with the city of Bruges,
which is where Petrus Christus painted and an incredibly wealthy city, part of the territories
ruled by Philip the Good, the Duke of Burgundy. He was one of the
wealthiest men in Europe. - [Steven] We're looking
in a jeweler's stall, a small shop that would have
opened up onto the street, and if you look carefully and
you can see a convex mirror that's reflecting the street beyond us. That is literally what is behind us as we look at this painting. - [Beth] It extends the
space of the painting so that we join these two figures who are looking into
the goldsmith's stall. - [Steven] But there are already two customers in that store. - [Beth] And one of
them, the female figure, seems to be gesturing
toward the goldsmith, who holds in his hand a
balance in which we see a ring, and in his right hand,
he's holding some weights as if to balance, to weigh,
the amount of gold in the ring. - [Steven] And that balance is so delicately held and painted. There's a long history of
representing a balance, the weighing, in the history
of art, but generally, it's St. Michael at the end of time weighing the goodness or evil of souls to decide who goes to
heaven and who goes to hell. - [Beth] Standing next to the scales is a container for the weights
and money, gold and silver. Behind the goldsmith,
we see not only wares that he's fashioned that are
available, perhaps for sale or to demonstrate the kinds
of things he can make, but we also see the
raw goods of his trade. - [Steven] I can make out coral, pearls, both seed pearls and larger pearls, what looks like amber. There are fossilized shark teeth. There's clear crystal
and there's porphyry. All of these exquisite
and expensive materials. - [Beth] And the wealth here
is signified, in addition, by the textiles worn by the couple, - [Steven] especially the woman. She wears this sumptuous outfit
that is richly appointed. There's so much gold in it. Clearly, this is not a common woman. - [Beth] If we look at the
two figures in the back, their faces seem much more generalized than the figure in the foreground, and when conservators have
examined the painting, they've noted that there
is a lot more attention paid to the underdrawing
of the seated goldsmith than of the couple in the back. So it's likely that the figure
in the front is a portrait. Now, art historians think
that the female figure represents the grandniece
of Philip the Good, the Duke of Burgundy,
who just at this time had arranged a marriage for
her with the king of Scotland. So she's about to become
the queen of Scotland and Philip the Good, the Duke, sent her off with incredible
treasures for her marriage, gold, silver, the most luxurious fabrics. He spent a fortune, and
one of the things he did was give her gold and silver objects commissioned from some
goldsmiths in Bruges. - [Steven] And so, now we're
in the realm of conjecture, but we think that this painting
might have been commissioned by the goldsmith himself, that is, that this was something
that he could have hung up in his guildhall or
perhaps even in his shop to show off the fact that
he had been patronized by Philip the Good, but
it's important to note that the woman is not a portrait of Philip the Good's grandniece. That would have been presumptuous to include her in this kind of painting. - [Beth] We're not sure
who is the male figure as we're not sure which goldsmith this is. There were several who furnished items for Philip the Good for his grandniece. The idea is, I'm a talented
and sought-after goldsmith, and I have royal patrons. There's possibly another
reading here that art historians like to offer, and that
is one much more in line with the traditions of
the Northern Renaissance, where we tend to see
objects from everyday life that also have a religious interpretation, much like the scales we talked about. - [Steven] In the mirror,
outside we can see two young men, well-dressed, with a falcon,
which is sometimes read as a symbol of pride and greed. And so, there's this contrast
that's being constructed between the outside world,
the world where things are less perfect, whereas inside, you have this notion
of harmony and balance. The other object on the counter
in front of us is a belt, and some art historians read that as also associated with
matrimony, with the wedding. - [Beth] But look at what
Petrus Christus can do. He has spent so much effort
creating an incredible illusion of reality, the way that
sash hangs over this tabletop where we can see the grain of the wood, the way that light glistens
on the metal surfaces here, like that gold around the convex mirror, these precise shadows that are cast. Everything is painted with such detail that you get the sense
that it was important to the artist and the patron
that all of these objects be represented as
realistically as possible. - [Steven] There's an interesting
relationship in the North between the representation
of jewels and divinity. In so many paintings by
Jan van Eyck, for example, God is shown encrusted with jewels. And so, here in this more
secular context, it's important to remember that lavish
jewelry could be a means with which to represent the divine. - [Beth] We know that some of the objects are destined for the church. For example, we see a crystal container, sitting on top of that a pelican, which is a symbol of God's
sacrifice for mankind. This is a container that likely
would have held the wafers, the bread, that became the body of Christ during the sacrament of
the Eucharist during mass. Look at how carefully Christus
has painted the reflections on those objects or the wooden
shutters that have opened in the window, a kind of
attention to everyday facts. That's an important
part of Renaissance art. - [Steven] And all of this specificity, all of this extraordinarily
rich color and texture is a result of the
innovation of oil paint, which Flemish artists had
mastered in the 15th century and which we see here brilliantly worked. This is oil paint that
allows for the distinction of the stitches of gold
in the woman's dress, as opposed to the clarity of the mirror or the cracks that we
can see in the mirror. It allows for the softness of the velvets versus the slippery, hard
quality of the coral. It is literally oil that
makes this painting possible. (gentle music)