Main content
Medieval Europe + Byzantine
Course: Medieval Europe + Byzantine > Unit 9
Lesson 5: Romanesque art in Spain- Historiated capitals, Church of Sant Miquel, Camarasa (Noguera)
- Virgin from Ger
- Wise and Foolish Virgins, Sant Quirze de Pedret
- The Painted Apse of Sant Climent, Taüll, with Christ in Majesty
- Camel from San Baudelio de Berlanga
- Conservation: Cast of the Pórtico de la Gloria
© 2023 Khan AcademyTerms of usePrivacy PolicyCookie Notice
Historiated capitals, Church of Sant Miquel, Camarasa (Noguera)
Historiated capitals from the crossing of the Church of Sant Miquel of the castle of Camarasa (Noguera), early 13th century, stone, 77 x 1.65 x 77.5 cm (Museu Nacional d'Art de Catalunya, Palau Nacional, Barcelona). Created by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker.
Want to join the conversation?
- Can anyone explain why angels tend to default to the female gender in modern discussions (see), when they all have masculine names (Michael, Gabriel, Lucifer, etc.)? 2:29(4 votes)
- I suppose it's because people have no understanding of what angels look like but they see them as being compassionate and merciful, and females are usually put under this description. But many Bible scholars believe that ALL angels ( if they have a gender ) are male because man was created before woman and angels before man. Genesis 1-2(9 votes)
- what are capitals? also did anyone notice that the snake (Satin) in the Adam and Eve story had four eyes?(4 votes)
- Capitals are the tops (caps) of pillars or columns, and no, I didn't see the four eyes.(4 votes)
- Does the figure of Eve remind anyone of the simplicity of Sumerian art (i.e. votive figures from Tel Asmar), with her wide staring eyes and simple upright pose?(4 votes)
- I think that's an apt comparison, but I'd doubt that there was any direct connection between the Sumerian and the Romanesque in this case.(1 vote)
- What does the term Romanesque mean? And why do their hands look out of proportion?(2 votes)
- From the author:Here's some more information on the Romanesque period:http://smarthistory.khanacademy.org/Romanesque.html
The artists of this time were very interested in telling a story clearly to a largely illiterate public. And telling a story is easier when you enlarge the hands so the gestures are clearly readable. This was more important to the artists of this period than being realistic.(4 votes)
- Would this been painted like ancient Greece art? And why is a hole in the ear of Abraham?(2 votes)
- Maybe there's a hole in his ear to let the sound in.(2 votes)
- What kind of order are these columns?(1 vote)
- the acanthus leaves would point to corinthian, but nothing remains the same forever.(2 votes)
- It is said that the eyes were "drilled" out, but I was under the impression that Michelangelo was the pioneer of this technique in the statue of David. Am I wrong or is the method used for David a new form of drilling but not the first form?(1 vote)
- Is the material of this columns different from the used per example in greece? It seems less sculptable(1 vote)
Video transcript
[MUSIC PLAYING] SPEAKER 1: Let's take
a look at this capital. It's what would be referred to
as a historiated capital, which is to say that it's a
capital that actually has a narrative carved into it. The most obvious
and recognizable and decorative element,
and not-narrative element, are the representation of
acanthus leaves, which come out of Greek and then
Roman architecture. But this is later, this is
medieval, this is 13th century. SPEAKER 2: And one of things
one notices about them immediately is how
deeply carved they are. So you have these
lovely dark shadows forming the edges of the leaves. SPEAKER 1: One of
the first elements that you see is the story of the
original sin, the story of Adam and Eve. SPEAKER 2: Both of whom
look really terrified. SPEAKER 1: They
do look terrified, and they're both
covering themselves. That tells us what specific
moment in the story it is. They know their nakedness. And God is probably
at this moment confronting them and asking
them why they hide from him. SPEAKER 2: I love the
way that their eyes are drilled with
these deep holes. And then you have these large
oval shapes around them, so they just look like
their eyes are bulging out of their heads from the
terrible recognition of what they've done and
how they've betrayed God. SPEAKER 1: They've
actually seemed to have plucked one of
the leaves of acanthus from the capital next to them
in order to cover themselves. And that's what they
hold between their hands. SPEAKER 2: Eve
especially as she grips the top of that leaf to
her chest and her hair fans out like a flame, which is
just a really powerful image of the knowledge of
what they've done. And the consequences of what
their actions are going to be are already present here. SPEAKER 1: It's wildly
emotional in that sense. And I think in the
21st century we would even say
psychological now. There's another
Old Testament scene that's represented
on this capital. If we move to the
right, you actually have a pretty complicated image
of a large arching figure. An angel, you can see
the angel's wings. SPEAKER 2: She's got her
arms around two figures. SPEAKER 1: And it's
Abraham and Isaac. SPEAKER 2: And of course both
of these figures are stumpy and not in correct proportion. That way that we kind
of think of as medieval in their draperies
indicated by lines. SPEAKER 1: Right,
as opposed to form. SPEAKER 2: So this
is Abraham obviously about to kill Isaac, his son,
and the angel who stops him from doing this terrible thing. And you know this story
is a prefiguration of the story of the
crucifixion of Christ. SPEAKER 1: But it's also a
critically important story in terms of the necessity
of one's absolute obedience to God. SPEAKER 2: The
protectiveness of the angel, of her arms, her wings
covering the figures. And the way that her head forms
the corner of that capital I think is very powerful. SPEAKER 1: But what's
interesting is that the angel's face is not looking down
to Abraham and Isaac, but in some more direct
way looking out to us. In fact, they all seem
to be looking out to us. In a sense, beseeching us
to follow this example. SPEAKER 2: The portals of
many Romanesque churches were decorated with scenes
of the last judgment. And the idea was as
you walked in you were reminded of
the price of sin. The price of sin was
eternity in hell. These are the
choices that we face as humans about what we
can do with our lives. SPEAKER 1: Nobody
is going to accuse Romanesque sculptors
of being subtle. SPEAKER 2: And they're very
powerful and very emotional. And they may have taken us
a few moments to decode, and visitors to the museum
may have to look at a label. But there was no doubt
that anyone entering the church in the
12th or 13th century would have been able to read
these stories very easily. SPEAKER 1: Yes, these would
have been very direct messages and constant reminders. [MUSIC PLAYING]