Fernand Khnopff, I Lock My Door Upon Myself, 1891 (Neue Pinakothek, Munich) Speakers: Dr. Beth Harris & Dr. Steven Zucker. Created by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker.
Want to join the conversation?
- Rossetti was a poet very concerned with death and mortality. To what end do you think the painting reflects this, perhaps in its colour choice or subject?(4 votes)
- Somber, ambiguous colors. There is no light source to create shadows.The painting reminds me of a imaginary traditional Japanese interior.(6 votes)
- Could it be possible that the dark figure in the town is Thanatos, the god of death? Considering the fact that the sculpture is Hypnos, his brother, and the figure seems to be wearing dark robes like a grim reaper. Is she hiding from death, and that is why she locks the door upon herself?(5 votes)
- Yes, I thought about the exact thing this morning. That figure seems as if to be at her door, doesn't it? It is there or waiting for her.(3 votes)
- This isn't the creation of "Symbolism", or rather, the first time symbolism has been used in painting though, correct? I remember the lilies in medieval paintings (symbolizing Mary's virginity) and the Eagle and the Lamb (symbolizing various evangelists and such) long before this era of painting. What about this era is so different from those earlier times that clearly used symbols imbued with meaning?(2 votes)
- Ah... good question Jeff! The name for this movement "Symbolism" in the late nineteenth century is a bit of a misnomer (as artistic styles often art!). And these artists don't use symbols in the way that artists did for most of art history, where an object generally symbolizes or suggests (usually) one idea (for example lilies symbolize the purity of the Virgin Mary - http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/bota/hd_bota.htm). Instead the Symbolists were reacting against what they saw as the materialism of Impressionism - it's embrace of the modern world, and of the world we see with our eyes. The Symbolists were interested instead in ambiguity, in the dream, in the imagination, in poetry. It's one of my favorite periods in art history :) and indeed this is one of my favorite paintings... Here's a good summary: http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/symb/hd_symb.htm(4 votes)
- In3:27,what is melancoly?
Is It spelled right?
And,what does it mean?
Thank you!!(1 vote)
- From dictionary.com, the word "melancholy" is defined as "a gloomy state of mind, especially when habitual or prolonged; depression".(3 votes)
- At4:08, rather than spear or arrow, isn't that black line similar to a space between two tables? Also, the blue object at the end of that line is not a triangle, rather it is continuing downwards and has a similar pattern to the blue cloth-like object in front of the woman. Do you think that they are the same object?(1 vote)
(piano playing) Steven: We're in Munich at the Neue Pinakothek, and we're looking at the work of a Belgian artist, Fernand Khnopff. Beth: The title of the painting is, "I Lock My Door Upon Myself," from a poem by Christina Rossetti, called "Who Shall Deliver Me?" Steven: I'm always interested by the visual arts when they have corollary in literature or in music. The way in which artists try to create a kind of alliance between the openness of words, and the way in which we can visualize in our imagination. But, how can that then be treated in something that we can see? Beth: I think it's real conundrum that painters, since the renaissance, have tried to deal with, including artists like Botticelli. The stanza in the poem that this is from goes like this: "I lock my door upon myself, "And bar them out; but who shall wall "Self from myself, most loathed of all?" This is, in some ways, a religious poem about inner struggle and the way that God can, in the end, provide salvation. But, to me, this idea of inner struggle and inner turmoil is very much the subject of so many symbolist paintings, this inner life. Steven: And so, we have this image that is very narrow in its tonality, so that there is not much distinction between, for instance, these beautiful flowers, these lilies in the foreground that space across this frieze almost creating a kind of rhythm that speaks to the rhythm of poetry. Beth: Or, reminding me of a medieval painting, like a triptych in its [tri par tight] division, and the woman in the front who spans two of those parts of the painting. Steven: That woman is not enacting anything in an obvious sense. There is no theatrical gesture. She is quiet and contemplative, but in a way that allows for the ideas of the painting to, in a sense, be embodied by her. Beth: Khnopff was inspired by the Pre-Raphaelites, who painted about 40 years before him. Steven: So, the symboists are creating meaning by association, by feeling, and by symbol, as opposed to by an explicit narrative. Beth: I would say symbols that aren't very specific, but also open to interpretation. Steven: For instance, probably most evident is the sculptural head that's on the shelf in the background. We know that it's Hypos, the God of Sleep. Beth: The brother of Thanatos, the God of Death. Steven: Which seems to be completely in keeping with the mood of this painting. Beth: It does. Doesnt it? We have, on the right side, an image of a medieval townscape with a lone figure in it. Steven: That figure, seems to me, to be a contemplative, isolated figure, the way that we might think about [Fredricks Monks] earlier in this century. Beth: Then, on the left side, we see a door, but we can't really see the space that it opens into, and next to that, perhaps a mirror. Then, beside that, a decorative floral pattern. We have the lilies that are in the foreground. We have a lot of things that don't add up to a traditional narrative. Steven: Right. When we expect to see lilies, we tend to see white ones, and it speaks to Mary's virginity. These are not only orange lilies, but they're also dried. They've withered. There is something terribly melancholy about them. Beth: The female figure also looks off into the distance in a way that we can't read what she's feeling very clearly. Steven: As if that's not enough ambiguity, there are other elements in here that are just tantalizing. Note the very fine chain that hangs down, an unseen place in the middle of the canvas. There seems to be a little crown that hangs from it. Then, just to the right of that, in a rectangle, we can just make out what seem to be two circles, and what might be a face in the center. Beth: Then, the figure rests on a table that is reminiscent of an alter. On it, is a black cloth and a spear, or an arrow. What do all of these mean? If we look for explanation in the poem, we're not going to find it there. We're not going to find a meaning anywhere. This is really about evoking a mood, or a feeling. One way to think about that is that the impressionists, who came just before the symbolists, took the objective world and saw it through the lens of individual temperament. But, in symbolism, we a inner world made objective, made manifest, on the canvas. Steven: In a sense, the interior subjective self made universal as it's brought into the visual realm. Beth: We think about the title, "I Lock My Door Upon Myself," this focusing on the interior life, it brings us inside ourselves to find our own meaning and interpretation. (piano playing)