Under the *The expenditures approach* It shows: "Y=$200+$40+$35+$10−$15=$260 million" But the result shall be 270 million rather than 260 million

You are right, 200+40+35+10-15 is equal to 270.

Can someone explain to me why transfer payments are not included? If I buy a second hand television from someone am I not improving my (and presumably their) welfare? Or is that not what GDP is trying to measure. With that in mind, a more encompassing measure of GDP would surely be Income minus Savings. There must be some preexisting theory based on this logic somewhere?

The reason that transfer payments are not included is that they don't produce anything directly. The purpose of GDP is to capture what is produced, not a measure of wellbeing. Now, it is true that this measure of production is used as a proxy of wellbeing, but there is a later lesson on why that isn't a good idea and the limitations of GDP.

Why does gdp measurement only the value of good and service product with in country

Because that is what is intended to do! GDP is meant to be a snapshot of all of the market activity in an economy, with the idea that it should rise when times are good and fall when times are bad. It is not (and never was meant to be) a measure of wellbeing.

why is consumption in new housing excluded?

It is included in investment instead. Remember, investment is spending by firms AND households investing on NEW HOUSES, and consumption is household spending EXCEPT FOR NEW HOUSES.

I just don't understand the whole GDP system, why do we need it?

From what I understood, it is used as a marker to indicate how well a country is performing. It's basically used to find out how much a country manufactured different products for a particular time frame( month, quarter, year)

Main content

Course: AP®︎/College Macroeconomics > Unit 2

Lesson 1: The Circular Flow and GDP

Lesson summary: The circular flow and GDP

Google Classroom

In this lesson summary review and remind yourself of the key terms and calculations used in describing the output of an economy. Key topics include the expenditures approach, income approach, and value added approach to calculating GDP and why imports are subtracted from GDP.

Lesson Overview

Just how much stuff did the nation of Gerbilalia produce last year? We can use one of our key macroeconomic measures, gross domestic product (GDP), to figure this out.

GDP can be measured in three different ways: the value added approach, the income approach (how much is earned as income on resources used to make stuff), and the expenditures approach (how much is spent on stuff). However, you will likely run into the expenditures approach the most as you progress through this course.

A model called the circular flow diagram illustrates how the expenditures approach and the income approach must equal each other, with goods and services flowing in one direction and income flowing in the opposite direction, in a closed loop.

Key Terms

Term	Definition
gross domestic product (GDP)	the market value of the final production of goods and services within the geographic borders of a country in a given period; for example, if the GDP of India is $$ 2.264 trillion$ ‍ in 2016, this means that this is the value of all new goods and services that were produced inside the border of India, excluding intermediate goods, during 2016.
expenditures approach to GDP	one of the three approaches to calculating GDP that involves adding up all spending on final goods and services in an economy; the expenditures approach categories this spending into five categories: consumption, investment, government spending, exports, and imports: $Y = C + I + G + X - M$ ‍.
income approach to GDP	an approach to calculating GDP that involves adding up all of the income earned within the borders of a country in a given year; the income approach adds up wages, rents, interest, and profits.
value-added approach to GDP	an approach to calculating GDP that involved adding up all of the value added at various stages of production; for example, in the production of a cake that sells for $$ 12$ ‍, the value-added approach counts the value of the raw ingredients that a farmer sells to the baker ( $$ 4$ ‍), which a baker then combines with her capital to create a cake, which adds $$ 8$ ‍ in value.
final goods and services	the goods and services that are purchased by consumers, businesses, the government, or other countries in their final form for their intended final use; for example, a car purchased by a household, a haircut, or a laptop bought by a student.
intermediate goods	goods that are used in the production of a final product; for example, tires are final goods when Katherine buys them at the tire store. But when Acme Motor Company buys tires to build a car that they plan on selling, those tires would be considered intermediate goods.
consumption (C)	when using the expenditures approach, “C” is the category of GDP that is spending by households on final goods and services in a given year but excludes spending on new housing
investment (I)	when using the expenditures approach, “I” is the category of GDP that is spending businesses do in order to produce goods and services (such as buy computers for accountants to use or build factories to build cars); investment includes spending on capital goods (tools, equipment) and inventory.
government spending (G)	when using the expenditures approach, “G” is the spending by government entities, whether local or national governments, on goods and services such as building roads and national defense; note that transfer payments are not included in “government spending” in GDP even though it is something that is part of the money that a government might spend each year.
transfer payment	any payment by a government to a household that is not in exchange for a good or service; for example, if the government hires a contractor they are buying a service that is included in GDP, but if they send a retired person a pension check they are not buying a good or service and it is not counted in GDP.
exports (X)	goods that are produced in one country and then sold within another country; for example, if a producer in the United States makes $400$ ‍ Katnest Evergreen bobblehead dolls and sells them to a store in Japan, these dolls would be counted as Exports for the United States.
imports (M)	goods that are produced in a different country than where they were purchased; for example, those bobblehead dolls made in the U.S. are purchased by Japanese consumers, so they would get counted initially as consumption (“C”) for Japan. Since they do not reflect something that was produced in Japan, they are subtracted from Japan’s GDP as an import (“M”).
net exports X-M	spending on exports minus spending on imports’ “exports” is the value of goods that go out of a country, “imports” is the value of the goods that come into a country. There is a trade deficit when imports are higher than exports and there is a trade surplus and when exports are higher than imports.

Key Takeaways

Gross Domestic Product (GDP)

Gross domestic product (GDP) is a measure of the final output of a nation’s economy. GDP measures the total value of all new goods and services produced in an economy in a given year.

For example, in 2016 GDP in Japan was

$ 4.939 trillion

. This means that during 2016, Japan produced goods and services within its geographic borders that were sold for

$ 4.939 trillion

. GDP can be measured using 1) the expenditures approach, 2) the income approach, or 3) the value added approach. The three approaches are equivalent—regardless of which approach you use you should end up with the same value.

The circular flow diagram

GDP can be represented by the circular flow diagram as a flow of income going in one direction and expenditures on goods, services, and resources going in the opposite direction. In this diagram, households buy goods and services from businesses and businesses buy resources from households.

Key Graphical Model: The circular flow diagram

Figure 1: The circular flow diagram

The circular flow diagram illustrates the equivalence of the income approach and expenditures approach to calculating national income. In this diagram, goods, services, and resources move clockwise, and money (income from the sale of the goods, services, and resources) moves counterclockwise.

Individuals purchase goods and services from businesses, and their expenditures (the money they spend) go to businesses. Firms purchases resources, such as labor from households, and the money they pay for these resources go to households.

Key Mathematical Model: Two approaches to measuring GDP

The expenditures approach

GDP can be calculated using the expenditures approach using the following equation:

Y = C + I + G + X - M

Each component is described in the table below:

Category	definition
$C$ ‍	consumption: spending by households
$I$ ‍	investment: spending by businesses on capital and inventory
$G$ ‍	government spending: spending by all government entities on goods and services (but not transfer payments)
$X$ ‍	exports: goods and services produced within a country that are purchased in other countries
$M$ ‍	imports: goods and services that are produced in other countries but are purchased in your country.

For example, in 2016: Households in the nation of Fredonia spent

$ 200 million

on newly-produced goods and services.

$ 40 million

was spent by businesses on adding goods to their inventories and on new equipment to produce goods. The government spent a total of

$ 35 million

on goods and services. Additionally, businesses produced

$ 10 million

in goods and services that they sold overseas. Of all the goods and services purchased in the economy,

$ 15 million

were imported from overseas. Therefore, Fredonia’s GDP would be calculated as:

Y = $ 200 + $ 40 + $ 35 + $ 10 - $ 15 = $ 260 million

The income approach

GDP can be calculated using the income approach using the following equation:

Y = w + i + r + p

Where each category refers to the income received from supplying one of the four economic resources:

Category	definition
$w$ ‍	wages earned from labor
$i$ ‍	interest earned on capital
$r$ ‍	rent earned on land
$p$ ‍	profits earned on entrepreneurial talent

Common misperceptions

When people casually use the word “investments” in everyday language, they are typically referring to financial assets such as stocks and bonds. However, in the context of GDP, “investment” means real assets—the spending on physical equipment, research and development, and inventory.

For example, if a company buys a computer, that is physical equipment. If a company restocks its warehouse, that is building inventory. Both the equipment and inventory are counted in the investment category of GDP. A share of stock of a company is not considered an “investment” because it is an ownership claim rather than a real asset. When reading or writing about anything involving investment, make sure to specify whether you mean a real asset or a financial asset.

Not all government spending is counted in GDP; only what a government spends on goods and services is counted. In many countries, governments also have social welfare programs that do things like provide pensions for retired people or allocate money to people with lower incomes. These payments, called “transfer payments,” neither reflect actual production of a good by the person receiving the money nor a service provided by the person receiving the money. Therefore, they should not be counted in GDP. Nobody is “buying” grandma when she gets a pension check!

Discussion Questions

Why are imported goods deducted from the calculation of GDP?

The objective of GDP is to capture what is produced in your country. One of the more straightforward ways of doing this is to add up what is spent on goods and services by households, businesses, and the government. The problem with this approach is that not everything that households, businesses, and the government purchases every year is actually produced in their country. This means imports (goods produced in another country) must be subtracted in order to accurately capture what was produced in your country.

Give three examples of goods that your household purchased last year that would not be counted in GDP.
What does the circular flow diagram say about the relationship between the expenditures approach and the income approach to calculating GDP?

Want to join the conversation?

Sort by:

Liam Mullany
Posted 6 years ago. Direct link to Liam Mullany's post “Can someone explain to me...”
Can someone explain to me why transfer payments are not included? If I buy a second hand television from someone am I not improving my (and presumably their) welfare? Or is that not what GDP is trying to measure. With that in mind, a more encompassing measure of GDP would surely be Income minus Savings. There must be some preexisting theory based on this logic somewhere?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(4 votes)
Answer
- melanie
  Posted 6 years ago. Direct link to melanie's post “The reason that transfer ...”
  The reason that transfer payments are not included is that they don't produce anything directly. The purpose of GDP is to capture what is produced, not a measure of wellbeing. Now, it is true that this measure of production is used as a proxy of wellbeing, but there is a later lesson on why that isn't a good idea and the limitations of GDP.
  Button navigates to signup page
  (26 votes)
Allan
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Allan's post “Question 1: Imported good...”
Question 1: Imported goods are deducted from the calculation of GDP because they are produced in another country.

Question 2: Three examples of goods that my household purchased last year that would not be counted in GDP would be a used car made in Japan, a bottle made in China, a desk-lamp made in China.

Question 3: The circular flow diagram says the relationship between the expenditures approach and the income approach to calculating GDP are equal.
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(10 votes)
Answer
nasa
Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to nasa's post “Under the *The expenditur...”
Under the The expenditures approach

It shows:
"Y=$200+$40+$35+$10−$15=$260 million"
But the result shall be 270 million rather than 260 million
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(8 votes)
Answer
- Noah L.
  Posted 3 years ago. Direct link to Noah L.'s post “You are right, 200+40+35+...”
  You are right, 200+40+35+10-15 is equal to 270.
  Button navigates to signup page
  (3 votes)
Aman Bhardwaj
Posted 6 years ago. Direct link to Aman Bhardwaj's post “Why does gdp measurement ...”
Why does gdp measurement only the value of good and service product with in country
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(4 votes)
Answer
- melanie
  Posted 6 years ago. Direct link to melanie's post “Because that is what is i...”
  Because that is what is intended to do! GDP is meant to be a snapshot of all of the market activity in an economy, with the idea that it should rise when times are good and fall when times are bad. It is not (and never was meant to be) a measure of wellbeing.
  Button navigates to signup page
  (9 votes)
[Au]^79
Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to [Au]^79's post “why is consumption in new...”
why is consumption in new housing excluded?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(3 votes)
Answer
- gm
  Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to gm's post “It is included in investm...”
  It is included in investment instead. Remember, investment is spending by firms AND households investing on NEW HOUSES, and consumption is household spending EXCEPT FOR NEW HOUSES.
  Comment on gm's post “It is included in investm...”
  (4 votes)
Eileen Hu
Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to Eileen Hu's post “where did you talk about ...”
where did you talk about net investment and depreciation?
Button navigates to signup pageComment on Eileen Hu's post “where did you talk about ...”
(4 votes)
Answer
Allison Harvison
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Allison Harvison's post “I just don't understand t...”
I just don't understand the whole GDP system, why do we need it?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(1 vote)
Answer
- Bon Mas
  Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Bon Mas's post “From what I understood, i...”
  From what I understood, it is used as a marker to indicate how well a country is performing. It's basically used to find out how much a country manufactured different products for a particular time frame( month, quarter, year)
  Button navigates to signup page
  (4 votes)
Bon Mas
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to Bon Mas's post “With regards to import, w...”
With regards to import, when something gets imported, shouldn't the payment of tariffs be considered as an income even though the product wasn't manufactured in that country?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(2 votes)
Answer
emigracestroud5
Posted 4 years ago. Direct link to emigracestroud5's post “How do monetary funds flo...”
How do monetary funds flow into firms and how do monetary funds flow out of the firms?
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(2 votes)
Answer
Ernest Ngulube
Posted 5 years ago. Direct link to Ernest Ngulube's post “Do you include gross dome...”
Do you include gross domestic fixed capital consumption and capital consumption in the total domestic expenditure calculation
Button navigates to signup pageButton navigates to signup page
(2 votes)
Answer